Issue
Agron. Sustain. Dev.
Volume 27, Number 4, November-December 2007
Page(s) 387 - 397
DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/agro:2007021
Published online 18 December 2007
Agron. Sustain. Dev. 27 (2007) 387-397
DOI: 10.1051/agro:2007021

Improved multivariate analyses to discriminate the behaviour of faba bean varieties

Fabio Stagnaria, Andrea Onofrib, John Jr. Jemisonc and Mario Monottib

a  University of Teramo, Department of Food Sciences, Via C.R. Lerici, 1 - 64023 Mosciano S.Angelo (TE), Italy
b  University of Perugia, Department of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Borgo XX Giugno, 74 - 06121 Perugia (PG), Italy
c  University of Maine Cooperative Extension, 495 College Avenue, Orono, ME 04473, USA

(Accepted 3 March 2007; published online 18 December 2007)

Abstract - Agricultural systems of Southern European regions are often based on short rotations of winter cereals and are thus subject to agro-ecological problems such as decreasing biodiversity, loss of soil fertility and increasing reliance on mineral fertilisers. Introducing new crops such as new varieties of faba bean, and new production methods, e.g. different planting times, may increase the sustainability of farming systems. To advance the use of these methods, both multi-environment field experiments and improved statistical methods to summarise and interpret results are needed. This report summarizes experiments conducted over three years and two locations where we compared phenology, morphology and yield of six faba bean, Vicia faba L., genotypes, sown in November and February. We have analyzed the data using canonical variate and additive main effect multiplicative interaction (AMMI). We demonstrate how such methods may be useful to obtain relevant information about a more successful introduction of faba bean in southern Europe. Our results show that sowing in November is much more suitable to Southern European regions than a February planting. Indeed, for the November planting, beans flower earlier and pods fill before the drought period. Concerning morphology, November sown plants were taller of 0.93 m versus 0.79 m on average; gave a lower insertion of first fertile branch of 0.44 m versus 0.51 m; gave a higher number of lateral branching per plant, of 1.5 versus 0.8; and gave a higher number of pods per plant of 10.2 versus 7.6. On the average yield levels were the highest for November sown varieties, of 3.55 versus 2.66 t ha-1. These findings indicate autumn sown faba bean could be introduced in Southern European regions. Using adequate varietal selection, this crop may improve the agro-environmental sustainability of farming systems. These results also highlight the usefulness of canonical variate and AMMI analysis, as 576 morphological data, e.g. 6 varieties, 2 sowing times, 6 environments and 8 variables, and 72 yield data, e.g. 6 varieties, 2 sowing times and 6 environments, can be summarised in two bi-plots, clearly depicting the effect of sowing dates on crop morphology and yield, across locations and years. Such methods deserve a more widespread use when it is necessary to interpret crop response to environmental and agronomic factors.


Key words: faba bean / genotypes / Mediterranean environments / canonical variates / AMMI analysis

Corresponding author: fstagnari@unite.it

© INRA, EDP Sciences 2007